• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Recommended Books
  • Programs
  • Online Dating Video Tips
  • Sitemap
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Thank You

Online Dating

Revealing Facts and Information

  • Articles
  • Information
  • Tips
  • Advice
  • Personal Development
  • Dating News
  • Products

Home » Advice

How to Write a First Message in Online Dating That Gets Replies

Published March 8, 2010 · Last updated November 17, 2026 · by Online Dating Fix Editorial Team

The best online dating first message is short, personal and easy to answer. Mention something specific from their profile, add a little about yourself, and finish with an open question. For example: “Your photo from the Grand Canyon looks amazing. I hiked it last spring. Did you go down to the river?” Messages like this get far more replies than “hey” or a compliment about looks.

The first message is where many good matches are lost. People get dozens of generic openers, so a thoughtful one stands out right away. This guide gives you a simple formula, real examples and the mistakes to avoid.

Why first messages matter

On most dating apps, people decide in seconds whether to reply. A message that shows you read their profile tells them you are interested in them as a person. A generic message tells them you are sending the same line to everyone.

You do not need to be clever or funny. You just need to be specific and friendly.

The simple first message formula

Use this three-part formula:

  1. Notice something specific. A photo, a hobby, a prompt answer or a place they mention.
  2. Share a small connection. Something about you that relates to it.
  3. Ask an open question. One that cannot be answered with yes or no.

Here is the formula in action: “I see you love Italian food. I’m still searching for good carbonara in this city. Do you have a favorite spot?”

15 first message examples

Based on photos

  • “Is that your dog in the third photo? He looks like he has strong opinions about squirrels. What’s his name?”
  • “That mountain view is incredible. Where was that taken?”
  • “You look very serious about that pizza. Homemade, or do you have a favorite place?”

Based on hobbies

  • “You mentioned rock climbing. Are you more of an indoor gym person or outdoor routes?”
  • “A fellow runner! Are you training for anything right now?”
  • “You said you’re learning guitar. What’s the first song you wanted to master?”

Based on prompts or bio

  • “Your ‘perfect Sunday’ sounds a lot like mine. What’s the best brunch you’ve found?”
  • “I have to ask about your ‘unpopular opinion.’ How did you end up defending pineapple on pizza?”
  • “You said you’re happiest near the ocean. Beach day or boat day?”

When there is not much to go on

  • “Your profile is a bit of a mystery. What’s something you’re looking forward to this month?”
  • “Quick question to start things off: coffee or tea, and how do you take it?”
  • “What’s the best thing that happened to you this week?”

Light and playful

  • “Two truths and a lie, go. I’ll guess.”
  • “If you could only eat one cuisine for the rest of your life, what would it be?”
  • “What’s your go-to karaoke song, and are you brave enough to sing it?”

First message mistakes to avoid

  • “Hey” or “Hi” on its own. It puts all the work on the other person.
  • Only complimenting looks. “You’re gorgeous” is nice, but it does not start a conversation and can feel shallow.
  • Copy and paste messages. People can tell, especially if the message does not fit their profile.
  • Very long messages. A paragraph about your life story is too much for a first message.
  • Sexual comments. They make most people uncomfortable and often get you blocked.
  • Negativity. Complaining about dating apps or past dates is not a great opener.

How to keep the conversation going

Once they reply, keep it balanced:

  • Answer their questions and ask one back.
  • Share stories, not just facts. “I love hiking” becomes “I got lost on a trail last summer and found the best waterfall.”
  • Pick up on details they mention and follow up later.
  • Use humor if it feels natural.

After a few good exchanges, suggest a short video call or a casual date. Waiting weeks can cause the spark to fade. Our list of first date ideas can help you suggest something easy.

What if they do not reply?

Not every message gets an answer, even a great one. People may be busy, inactive, dating someone else or simply not interested. Do not send repeated follow-ups. One gentle nudge after a few days is fine, but then move on.

If many of your messages go unanswered, look at your profile too. Clear photos and a specific bio make your messages more likely to be read. See our guides on how to write a dating profile and how to get more matches.

Messages to send when a chat goes quiet

Sometimes a good conversation slows down after a few days. Before you give up, try one light message that gives the other person an easy way back in:

  • “I just tried that coffee place you mentioned. You were right about the pastries.”
  • “Random question: what’s the best thing you’ve watched lately?”
  • “Still thinking about your travel story. Did you ever make it back there?”

If they reply, great. If not, let it go without a follow-up. One friendly nudge is enough.

Who should message first?

Anyone can. Some apps require one person to message first, but on most apps either person can start. People who send the first message tend to have more conversations, because they choose who to talk to instead of waiting.

According to a Pew Research Center study, many online daters say they do not get as many messages as they would like, while others feel overwhelmed. Sending the first message puts you in control either way.

Keep it safe from the start

Friendly messages should never mean sharing private details too soon. Keep your last name, address, workplace and phone number private until you trust someone. Be cautious of matches who move very fast or ask for money. The Federal Trade Commission explains the warning signs of romance scams. For more on manners, read our guide to online dating etiquette.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good first message on a dating app?

A good first message mentions something specific from their profile and asks an open question. For example: “Your travel photos are great. Which trip was your favorite?” Short, personal and friendly works best.

Should my first message be long or short?

Short. One to three sentences is ideal. It is easy to read and reply to. Save longer stories for when the conversation is flowing.

Is it okay to compliment someone’s looks in a first message?

A light compliment is fine, but pair it with a question about something else in their profile. Messages that only mention looks get fewer replies and can feel shallow.

How long should I wait for a reply?

Give it a few days. People check apps at different times. If there is no reply after about a week, it is best to move on and focus on other matches.

Should I use pickup lines on dating apps?

Generic pickup lines rarely work because they are not personal. A playful question tied to their profile is a much better icebreaker.

Can I send the same first message to several matches?

You can reuse a structure, but always add a personal detail from each profile. Fully copied messages are easy to spot and usually get ignored. A few seconds of personalizing makes a big difference.

Online Dating Fix Editorial Team

Our editors research and write practical, safety-first advice for people dating online: choosing a site, writing a profile, first dates, avoiding scams and building lasting relationships. Articles are reviewed against trusted sources such as the FTC, Pew Research Center and the American Psychological Association, and updated as dating apps and scams change. Online Dating Fix is operated by Support Bay, LLC, Los Angeles, California. More about us.

Filed Under: Advice, Articles Tagged With: dating, dating free, dating online, dating site, dating site free, free dating website, online dating

Primary Sidebar

Featured Video

Advertisement

Receive FREE Dating Tips and Advice

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Recent Posts

  • Self-Help Tips For The Average Jane Or Joe

    Self improvement is about taking action to improve yourself as a person. It will help you attain many personal goals while gaining knowledge to increase spiritual growth. This article is your source for top-flight self-improvement strategies. Remember, begin you self improvement journey slowly, and, before long, you will begin to understand more about yourself. TIP! […]Read More »
  • Things Everyone Can Do To Help Personal Development

    Self improvement is all about making positive changes in yourself so that you can have a better life. You need to learn which self improvement strategies work and which don’t work as you pursue your goals for self improvement. There are some great ideas for self improvement in the article below. TIP! Perhaps stress is […]Read More »
  • Today Is The Day You Learn To Master Personal Development

    You may have been issued an ultimatum by your loved ones that you’ll lose them unless you significantly change your behavior. How do you start to make such a drastic change in your personal life, and allow for personal development? The following article provides you with advice that can get you started on the road […]Read More »
Subscribe by RSS Contact us
Search this site
BigCrumbs
  • Popular

Follow Us!

  • Facebook
  • Flickr
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Copyright © 2015 · Created by BuyingWebsites.info · WordPress ·